| Mr. Karl Seibel | 1883 to 1886 |
| Mr. William F. Bennhoff | 1927 to 1946 |
| Mr. Carl Dunk | 1946 to 1949 |
| Mr. Carl W. Greinke | 1949 to 1960 |
| Mr. Guenther K. Herzog | 1960 to 1963 |
| Mr. Robert C. Stebbe | 1964 to 1967 |
| Mr. Albert L. Hennig | 1967 to 1984 |
| Mr. James F. Smith | 1984 to 1989 |
| Mr. Walter Halimann | 1989 to 1993 |
| Mr. W. John Meinzen | 1993 to 1996 |
| The Rev. Joel A. Brondos, STM | 1996 to 2005 |
| The Rev. Thomas A. Sabel | 2005 to 2006 |
| The Rev. R. Eric Malmstrom | 2006 to Present |