| The Rev. Fred Dreyer | First Pastor | September 1883 | to | July 1886 |
| The Rev. Henry J. Juengel | Senior | February 1887 | to | June 1899 |
| The Rev. Henry C. Luehr | Senior | October 1899 | to | March 1927 |
| The Rev. Prof. Martin Luecke | Pulpit Assistant | 1902 | to | April 1926 |
| The Rev. J. Theodore Destinon | Associate | November 1923 | to | July 1926 |
| The Rev. Prof. Paul Bente | Pulpit Assistant | 1928 | to | October 1956 |
| The Rev. Henry C. Luehr | Assistant | March 1927 | to | February 1928 |
| The Rev. Paul Dannenfeldt | Senior | May 1927 | to | July 1956 |
| The Rev. Herman Zehnder | Assistant | April 1942 | to | August 1946 |
| The Rev. Leland R. Larson | Assistant | October 1946 | to | July 1948 |
| The Rev. Herman Heine | Assistant | January 1949 | to | February 1954 |
| The Rev. Bernard W. Johnson | Assistant | October 1954 | to | July 1956 |
| The Rev. Bernard W. Johnson | Senior | July 1956 | to | December 1962 |
| The Rev. Roland G. Friedrichs | Assistant | September 1956 | to | July 1958 |
| The Rev. Ronald C. Starenko | Assistant | November 1958 | to | April 1961 |
| The Rev. Marion F. Pierson | Assistant | September 1961 | to | February 1968 |
| The Rev. Charles J. Seevers | Senior | June 1963 | to | May 1966 |
| The Rev. Loren J. Shiley | Senior | January 1967 | to | October 1977 |
| Vicar Norman S. Meyer | Vicar | August 1968 | to | August 1969 |
| Vicar William H. Winkler | Vicar | August 1969 | to | August 1970 |
| Vicar Donald C. Winkler | Vicar | August 1970 | to | August 1971 |
| Vicar Michael D. Haupt | Vicar | August 1971 | to | August 1972 |
| Vicar Philip W. Backman | Vicar | August 1972 | to | August 1973 |
| Vicar Todd W. Roberts | Vicar | August 1973 | to | August 1974 |
| The Rev. Philip W. Backman | Assistant | January 1975 | to | April 1976 |
| The Rev. Walter L. Barth | Visitation Pastor | May 1976 | to | July 1996 |
| The Rev. Walter L. Barth | Vacancy Pastor | October 1977 | to | May 1978 |
| The Rev. Jerrold L. Nichols | Senior | May 1978 | to | October 1986 |
| The Rev. James W. Voelz, PhD | Pastoral Assistant | January 1984 | to | July 1988 |
| Vicar Bruce Boyce | Vicar | August 1986 | to | August 1987 |
| The Rev. Robert W. Schaibley | Senior | November 1986 | to | August 1995 |
| Vicar Kevin Karner | Vicar | August 1987 | to | August 1988 |
| The Rev. James G. Bollhagen, ThD | Pastoral Assistant | August 1988 | to | August 1992 |
| Vicar Marvin Metzger | Vicar | August 1988 | to | August 1989 |
| Vicar Douglas Handrich | Vicar | August 1989 | to | August 1990 |
| Vicar Jon Coyne | Vicar | August 1990 | to | August 1991 |
| The Rev. Paul M. Kaiser MDiv | Assistant Pastor | August 1992 | to | August 1995 |
| The Rev. Paul M. Kaiser MDiv | Associate | August 1995 | to | August 2001 |
| The Rev. Matthew C. Harrison STM | Senior | November 1995 | to | February 2001 |
| The Rev. Joel A. Brondos STM | Headmaster | July 1996 | to | June 2005 |
| Vicar Peter Marth | Vicar | June 2001 | to | June 2005 |
| The Rev. Paul M. Kaiser MDiv | Senior | August 2001 | to | June 2003 |
| The Rev. Joel A. Brondos STM | Assoc/Vacancy Pastor | June 2003 | to | November 2003 |
| The Rev. R. Eric Malmstrom MDiv | Assist. Pastor/Teacher | August 2003 | to | July 2006 |
| The Rev. Douglas D. Punke MDiv | Senior | November 2003 | to | Present |
| The Rev. R. Eric Malmstrom MDiv | Assoc/Headm/Teacher | July 2006 | to | Present |